The Disruption Dilemma
"Disruption" is a business buzzword that has gotten out of control. Today everything and everyone seem to be characterized as disruptive -- or, if they aren't disruptive yet, it's only a matter of time before they become so. In this book, Joshua Gans cuts through the chatter to focus on disruption in its initial use as a business term, identifying new ways to understand it and suggesting new tools to manage it.
Almost twenty years ago Clayton Christensen popularized the term in his book The Innovator's Dilemma, writing of disruption as a set of risks that established firms face. Since then, few have closely examined his account. Gans does so in this book. He looks at companies that have proven resilient and those that have fallen, and explains why some companies have successfully managed disruption -- Fujifilm and Canon, for example -- and why some like Blockbuster and Encyclopedia Britannica have not. Departing from the conventional wisdom, Gans identifies two kinds of disruption: demand-side, when successful firms focus on their main customers and underestimate market entrants with innovations that target niche demands; and supply-side, when firms focused on developing existing competencies become incapable of developing new ones.
Gans describes the full range of actions business leaders can take to deal with each type of disruption, from "self-disrupting" independent internal units to tightly integrated product development. But therein lies the disruption dilemma: A firm cannot practice both independence and integration at once. Gans shows business leaders how to choose their strategy so their firms can deal with disruption while continuing to innovate.
Press and Media
- Hogan Lovels, "Q&A with Joshua Gans," Global Media and Telecommunications Watch, 15 February 2017.
- Rebecca Rolfes, "The Law of Supply Disruption and Demand Disruption," Insigniam Quarterly, November 2016.
- John McManus, "Three Words," Builder, 16 October 2016.
- Wisetalk, Interview on the Disruption Dilemma, 18 August 2016.
- Joshua Gans, "Why Elon Musk's New Strategy Makes Sense," HBR Blogs, 25 July 2016.
- Clancy Yeates, "Disruption claims often overcooked -- if you believe the hype," Sydney Morning Herald, 28 June 2016.
- Emma Jacobs, "Book Review: 'The Disruption Dilemma'," Financial Times, 22 May 2016.
- Justin Lahart, "From Lending Club to Theranos, the Limits of Disruption," Wall Street Journal, 13 May 2016.
- Diane Coyle, "Surviving disruption through paranoia," The Enlightened Economist, 11 May 2016.
- Laura Montgomery, "Disruption: how it happens and how to handle it," The Economist Blog, 27 April 2016.
- Joshua Gans, "If Ford wants to beat Tesla, it needs to go all in," HBR Blogs, 20 April 2016.
- Interview Innovation Navigation Show, Sirius XM Radio, 29 March 2016.
- Joshua Gans, "What would it take to disrupt a platform like Facebook," HBR Blogs, 23 March, 2016.
- WYNC The Takeaway Public Radio, "Destroying the Disruption Myth," 21 March 2016.
- Joshua Gans, "The other disruption," Harvard Business Review, March 2016, pp.78-85.
- Joshua Gans, "Keep Calm and Manage Disruption," Sloan Management Review, February 22, 2016.
- David Slocum, "16 New Books for Creative Leaders to Begin in 2016," Forbes, February 18, 2016
- Steve Denning, Forbes, 2nd December 2015.
This important and thought-provoking book has been a source of fresh, new insights for me. Even when Gans disagrees with my work, it has given me a chance to improve what the theory needs to say.
(Clayton M. Christensen, Professor, Harvard Business School and author of The Innovator's Dilemma)
A very good introduction to the game theory and institutions of “disruptive innovation,” the book also dispels many myths about that concept.
(Tyler Cowen, Professor, George Mason University and Blogger at Marginal Revolution)
Joshua Gans builds on decades of experience in strategy and technology to provide a novel and insightful approach to understanding the sources of disruption and strategies to defend against it.
(Susan Athey, The Economics of Technology Professor, Stanford University, and winner of the John Bates Clark Medal)
Joshua Gans has a rare combination of skills -- he's a highly rated economic theorist, he's a careful student of business strategy, and he's an extraordinary expositor. The result is a book that draws upon the deepest insights of economics, applies them to some of the most pressing strategy issues of the day, and delivers usable insights with his customary charm and grace.
(Justin Wolfers, Professor of Economics, University of Michigan)
What is disruption? Why does it matter? What can and should companies do about it? With compelling case studies and clear logic, The Disruption Dilemma cuts through the fog of the confused debate on this overused term and the weak thinking that has dominated the field of innovation and offers business and analysts the tools to think ahead.
(Luis Garicano, Professor of Economics and Strategy, London School of Economics)
Joshua Gans is not only one of the world's leading academics but also someone who is deeply engaged in the reality of disruptive change. In this beautifully written book he pulls the concept of disruption apart and then puts it back together again in ways that change our understanding of what drives successful innovation in profoundly important ways. Using compelling examples of real-world firms facing disruption, he shows that firms fail not only because they face competition from lower-end entrants serving new customers -- 'demand-driven disruption' -- but also because firms face 'supply-driven disruption' -- moments when the very things that they do well make it difficult to act in the new ways that change requires. He suggests that in these circumstances building a freestanding unit -- the common prescription for firms facing disruption -- is much less likely to be successful than insuring against disruption through building a thoroughly integrated, flexible organization. This is a book rooted in the very latest research that has critically important implications for the way in which every manager should think about -- and respond to -- disruption.
(Rebecca Henderson, University Professor, Harvard Business School)
Disruption is a concept that is widely cited but poorly understood. At last, Gans provides the clarity that innovators, incumbents, and academics have long been seeking.
(Erik Brynjolfsson, Director of the MIT Initiative on the Digital Economy, and coauthor of the New York Times Best Seller The Second Machine Age)